Uber loses court case, workers in California win.
Uber Must Face Lawsuit Over UberEats Drivers’ Expenses, California Supreme Court Rules
By Daniel Wiessner
(Reuters) – Uber Technologies Inc must face a California lawsuit claiming it should have covered UberEats drivers’ work-related expenses, the state’s top court said on Monday, in what could be a major blow to companies in the largest U.S. state and a win for labor advocates.
The California Supreme Court in a unanimous ruling said UberEats driver Erik Adolph did not give up his right under state law to sue on behalf of a large group of workers even though he signed an agreement to bring his own work-related legal claims in private arbitration.
Adolph sued Uber in 2019, claiming the company misclassified UberEats drivers as independent contractors rather than employees, who must be reimbursed for work expenses under California law.
A unique California law called the Private Attorney General Act, or PAGA, allows workers to sue for employment law violations on behalf of the state and keep one-quarter of any money they win. The rest goes to the state to fund an agency that enforces labor laws.
The California Supreme Court said nothing in that law bars workers from pursuing claims on their own behalf in arbitration while separately litigating large-scale claims in court.
The decision likely undermines the significance of a 2022 U.S. Supreme Court ruling involving Viking River Cruises that said companies could force individual PAGA claims into arbitration, and could mean that California employers will face more large-scale lawsuits.
Theane Evangelis, a lawyer for Uber, said in a statement that Monday’s ruling conflicts with the Viking River decision and violates a federal law that requires enforcing valid arbitration agreements.
“We are considering our appellate options,” she said.
Michael Rubin, who represents Adolph, said the ruling could spur companies to reconsider forcing workers’ claims into arbitration if large-scale PAGA lawsuits can still proceed in court. Rubin also represented the plaintiff in the Viking River case.
More than half of private sector, nonunion U.S. workers are required to sign arbitration agreements as a condition of employment. The agreements typically bar them from filing or participating in traditional class action lawsuits.
Critics of mandatory arbitration say it discourages workers from bringing individual claims that involve small sums of money, and that workers who do bring disputes in arbitration are more likely to lose.
Business groups maintain that arbitration is quicker and more efficient than court, allowing workers to recoup more money. Trade groups hailed last year’s Viking River ruling, saying it would prevent plaintiffs in California from using PAGA as a way around arbitration.
Groups including the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, the country’s largest business lobby, filed briefs in Monday’s case warning the California Supreme Court that a ruling against Uber could encourage workers to file meritless lawsuits and pressure companies to settle them.
But the court said those concerns should be directed at state legislators, who have the power to change the law.
(Reporting by Daniel Wiessner in Albany, New York and Alison Frankel in New York; Editing by Alexia Garamfalvi and Josie Kao)
One America’s Jessamyn Dodd sits down with author and doctor Miriam Grossman to discuss her book ‘Lost In Trans Nation.’
Missouri Senator Eric Schmitt tells One America News a federal judge’s ruling in the lawsuit he brought against the Biden Administration when he was attorney general is “a big win for free speech and a blow to the Biden censorship regime.”
In the final part of an exclusive interview, Senator Rand Paul tells One America News more evidence is emerging that Doctors Fauci and Collins are not alone in their promotion of gain of function research.
45th President Donald Trump receives a major endorsement in Ron DeSantis’s backyard
(Reuters) – Salesforce appointed Wachtell, Lipton’s Sabastian Niles as its chief legal officer on Monday, months after the leading activist lawyer helped…
By John Kruzel WASHINGTON (Reuters) – A group of individual plaintiffs on Monday asked the U.S. Supreme Court to temporarily halt Microsoft’s…
By Nathan Gomes (Reuters) -Ford deepened a price war in the electric-vehicle industry on Monday by slashing the prices of its F-150…
LONDON (Reuters) – The United Nations Security Council will hold its first formal discussion on artificial intelligence (AI) this week in New…
" Conservative News Daily does not always share or support the views and opinions expressed here; they are just those of the writer."
Now loading...