Democratic Senator Faces Party Standoff Amid Corruption Charges
Sen. Robert Menendez (D-N.J.) is embroiled in a high-stakes battle within his own party, echoing the experiences of other scandal-plagued Democratic lawmakers. As calls for his resignation grow louder, a growing number of his colleagues on Capitol Hill are demanding that he step down.
Mr. Menendez is currently facing federal corruption charges, to which he has pleaded not guilty. Despite the allegations, he remains determined to stay in office, asserting his belief in his eventual exoneration.
“I firmly believe that when all the facts are presented, not only will I be exonerated, but I still will be New Jersey’s senior senator,” said Mr. Menendez, who temporarily stepped down as chair of the Senate Committee on Foreign Relations after the indictment was unsealed last week.
A similar act of defiance was displayed by former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo (D) amid allegations of sexual misconduct. Despite the accusations, Cuomo initially refused to resign but eventually succumbed to the pressure.
Former Sen. Al Franken (D-Minn.) also faced calls for his resignation from fellow Democrats after allegations of sexual misconduct. Franken ultimately stepped down, although he later expressed regret for not waiting for the Senate Ethics Committee to investigate.
As more Democratic Party leaders join the chorus demanding Menendez’s resignation, critics argue that Democrats themselves are disregarding the principle of innocent until proven guilty.
“Senator Menendez has a right to test the government’s evidence in court, just like any other citizen. He should be judged by jurors and New Jersey’s voters, not by Democratic politicians who now view him as inconvenient to their hold on power,” said Sen. Tom Cotton (R-Ark.).
Rep. George Santos (R-N.Y.), who is also facing federal charges, has come forward to defend Menendez’s right to due process.
“He’s innocent until proven guilty,” Mr. Santos added. “This—the media has to stop acting like everybody is guilty before they are even judged at by a jury. So no, I think everybody is innocent until proven guilty. When did we walk away from the fabric of our Constitution that everybody has a presumption of innocence?”
Mr. Santos reiterated his stance on X, emphasizing that the burden of proof lies with the government.
Rep. George Santos (R-N.Y.) leaves the Capitol Hill Club as members of the press follow him in Washington on Jan. 31, 2023. (Alex Wong/Getty Images)
Republican party leaders have refrained from calling for Mr. Santos’s resignation, with House Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) stating that “a person is innocent until proven guilty.”
The Democrats have criticized the decision to allow due process for Mr. Santos, arguing that it demonstrates the Republicans’ failure to hold their own accountable.
“Republicans don’t just fail to police their criminal leaders, they nominate them for president,” said Democratic strategist Matt Angle. He referred to former President Donald Trump’s legal troubles.
Republican strategist Brian Seitchik, in a rare moment of agreement, also supports the swift removal of Menendez.
“Bob Menendez is as dirty as the day is long, we knew that last decade when he was indicted, so this comes as not at all surprising … but it certainly is of note that Democrats have now piled on, specifically the governor of New Jersey and the junior Senator Cory Booker from New Jersey,” said Mr. Seitchik.
Menendez Could Create Political Problems For Democrats
The longer Mr. Menendez remains in office, the more electoral problems it could pose for Democrats as the scandal continues to overshadow other issues. Mr. Seitchik believes that regardless of the political headache it may cause for the Democratic Party, Menendez will stay put unless he is convicted.
“One of the lessons of modern politics for George Santos and for others is if you’re willing to endure the shame, then you get to keep your seat. They’re not going to force him out of office, he has to resign because he’s not going to be convicted in the immediate future—the legal system will take time. I just don’t see him getting out even though it will have an adverse impact on Democrats, both in New Jersey and nationally,” Mr. Seitchik explained.
Mr. Seitchik believes that when combined with the Hunter Biden scandal and the possibility of President Joe Biden’s impeachment, the Menendez scandal paints a troubling picture for Democrats on a national scale.
“It is too early to say what the mood of the country looks like. Although if you see the recent national polling (and national polling should be taken with a grain of salt) regarding the presidential campaign, there is legitimate movement in the last week or two in Trump’s direction,” he added.
He also suggested that if Menendez runs for re-election in 2024, he could be vulnerable to a Republican challenger.
“We have a dirty incumbent, an embattled incumbent. We have potentially (it’s way too early to say) but potentially an environment moving in the Republicans’ direction. Now, New Jersey just needs a Republican candidate who is a good candidate and a disciplined candidate with resources,” Mr. Seitchik concluded.
Sen. Bob Menendez (D-N.J.) (2nd L), with his wife Nadine Arslanian (R), leaves U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, in New York on Sept. 27, 2023. (Timothy A. Clary/AFP via Getty Images)
Menendez to Speak to Democratic Senators Thursday
Despite over two dozen Democratic senators calling for his resignation, Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) has not made a similar demand.
Speaking to reporters after Mr. Menendez’s court appearance, Mr. Schumer did not call for his resignation and announced that Mr. Menendez would address his Democratic colleagues on Thursday during a closed-door lunch.
“We all know that senators have a much higher standard. And clearly, when you read the indictment, Sen. Menendez fell way below that standard,” Mr. Schumer said, according to the AP.
It is expected that Mr. Schumer will make a decision regarding Mr. Menendez’s resignation after their meeting on Thursday. When asked directly by reporters, Mr. Schumer only responded, “We will see what happens.”
This is the second time Mr. Menendez has faced corruption charges. The previous indictment in 2015 resulted in a mistrial in 2018, with the judge ultimately issuing an acquittal due to the jury’s inability to reach a decision.
In the current case, Mr. Menendez and his wife, Nadine Arslanian Menendez, were indicted on multiple counts of conspiracy, including bribery, honest services fraud, and extortion. The charges allege that they accepted hundreds of thousands of dollars in bribes, including cash, gold, and contributions toward a mortgage.
Savannah Hulsey Pointer contributed to this report.
What factors are contributing to the pressure on Menendez to resign and how does it reflect a lack of consistency within the Democratic Party
The facts and evidence presented during a fair trial, rather than being condemned based on mere accusations,” said one supporter of Menendez, highlighting the importance of due process and the presumption of innocence.
However, those calling for Menendez’s resignation argue that the charges against him are serious and cannot be ignored. They point to the potential damage it could cause to the Democratic Party’s reputation and credibility if Menendez remains in office while facing corruption allegations.
Furthermore, they argue that Menendez’s refusal to step down undermines the party’s stance on ethical conduct and accountability. The Democratic Party has long advocated for government transparency and integrity, and allowing a senator facing corruption charges to continue in office contradicts these values.
Party unity and solidarity have also come into play, as some Democrats fear that Menendez’s corruption scandal could impact their chances in upcoming elections. The party needs to present a united front to voters and distance themselves from any politicians implicated in wrongdoing.
However, critics argue that the pressure on Menendez to resign reflects a lack of consistency within the Democratic Party. They cite examples of other Democratic lawmakers who faced similar allegations but were not met with the same level of opposition within their own party.
Some believe that there is a political motivation behind the calls for Menendez’s resignation, as he has been a vocal advocate for progressive policies and has clashed with some fellow Democrats on certain issues. They argue that his corruption charges are being used as a convenient excuse to remove him from the political arena.
Despite the controversy surrounding him, Menendez maintains his innocence and insists on staying in office. He believes that he can effectively carry out his duties as a senator while simultaneously defending himself against the corruption charges.
The standoff within the Democratic Party regarding Menendez’s future remains unresolved. As the corruption trial progresses, the party will need to carefully consider the potential consequences and the message it sends to the public about its commitment to ethics and accountability.
Regardless of the outcome, the situation serves as a reminder of the challenges faced by political parties when dealing with members embroiled in scandal. It raises questions about how party loyalty and principles should be balanced against allegations of wrongdoing and the public’s expectations of integrity from their elected representatives.
Now loading...