China’s economic miracle was partly illusory. Time for a reality check.

By Joe Cash

BEIJING (Reuters) – Chinese President Xi Jinping’s​ first major reform plans a ⁤decade ago ​were also his boldest, ⁢envisaging a transition to a Western-style free market economy driven by services and consumption by 2020.

The⁢ 60-point agenda was ⁤meant to fix⁤ an obsolete growth model‌ better‍ suited to ⁣less developed countries – however, most of those reforms have gone nowhere leaving the economy largely reliant on older policies that have only added to China’s massive debt pile and industrial overcapacity.

The failure to restructure the world’s second-largest economy has raised critical questions about what comes next for China.

While many analysts see a slow drift towards Japan-style stagnation as the most ⁣likely outcome, there ‍is also the prospect of a more severe crunch.

“Things always fail slowly until they suddenly break,” said William Hurst,⁢ Chong ​Hua Professor of Chinese Development at University of Cambridge.

“There is a significant risk in the short term of financial crisis or other degree of economic crisis that would carry very substantial social and political costs⁢ for the Chinese government. Eventually there’s going to have to be a reckoning.”

China came out​ of its ⁢Maoist planned economy in the 1980s as a largely rural society, badly in need⁤ of factories and infrastructure.

By the time the global financial crisis hit in 2008-09, it had already met most of ​its investment ‍needs​ for its‍ level of development, economists say.

Since then, the economy quadrupled⁢ in nominal terms while overall debt‍ expanded nine times. To keep growth high, China in the 2010s⁢ doubled down on infrastructure and ​property investment, at the expense of household consumption.

That has kept consumer⁣ demand weaker as ⁣a portion of​ GDP than ‍in⁣ most other countries and concentrated job creation in the ‌construction and industrial sectors, careers increasingly spurned by young university graduates.

The policy‌ focus also bloated China’s⁣ property sector to a quarter ⁣of economic activity⁣ and ⁣made local governments so⁢ reliant ‍on debt that⁣ many⁣ now struggle to refinance.

The pandemic,‍ a demographic downturn and‍ geopolitical ​tensions have exacerbated all these problems⁣ to the point that the economy has found it hard to recover this year⁢ even as China reopened.

“We’re at a moment when ‍we are‍ seeing some structural shifts, but we should⁢ have seen these coming,” said Max Zenglein, chief economist at MERICS, a China studies institute.

“We’re just beginning to be confronted with the reality. We’re in untested territory.”

The​ end of China’s⁤ economic boom will likely hurt⁣ commodity exporters and ⁣export disinflation around the world. At home, it will ‌threaten living standards for millions of unemployed graduates and many whose wealth is tied ⁢up in property, posing social stability risks.

CRISIS VS STAGNATION

Aside from short-term solutions, which would likely only perpetuate debt-fueled investment, economists see three options for China.

One is a swift, painful crisis that writes off debt, curbs excess industrial capacity and deflates ⁣the⁢ property bubble. Another is a decades-long ‌process in which China winds down ⁣these excesses gradually at the expense of growth. The third⁣ is switching to a consumer-led model with structural reforms that cause some near-term pain but help it re-emerge faster and‌ stronger.

A ​crisis⁤ could unfold if⁤ the massive property market collapses in an uncontrolled way, dragging the financial sector with it.

The other high-stress point is local government debt, estimated by the International Monetary Fund at $9 trillion. China promised in July to come up ​with a “basket of measures” to address municipal debt risks, without detailing.

Logan Wright, a partner at Rhodium Group, says Beijing has to decide which portion of that debt to rescue, as the amount is⁢ too large to provide​ full ⁢guarantees⁣ of repayment, which the market currently regards as implicit.

“Crisis is going to occur ⁤in China when government credibility falters,” he said.

“When all of a sudden⁢ funding is cut off for the remaining investments ⁢that seem subject to market risk, that’s a huge moment of uncertainty in China’s financial‍ markets.”

But given state control of many developers and‌ banks and a tight capital account that limits outflows into assets abroad, that is a low⁣ risk scenario,‍ many ⁢economists say.

Alicia Garcia⁢ Herrero, chief economist for Asia Pacific at Natixis, expects​ there would be ​plenty of buyers if ⁣Beijing consolidates debt given limited⁢ investment alternatives.

“I‌ am more in the slow growth camp,” she said. “The more ​debt is piled up for projects that are not productive, the lower the return on assets, particularly public investment, and ⁤that really means that ⁣China ‌cannot grow its way out.”

Avoiding a crisis by​ extending the adjustment period, however, has its own stability risks with youth unemployment topping 21% and around 70% of household ‌wealth​ invested in property.

“One of China’s biggest success stories, building a‍ strong middle class, is also becoming its biggest vulnerability,” said MERICS’ Zenglein. “If you look at ⁢it from the ‍perspective ⁤of a younger person, you ​are now at risk of being the first post-reform generation whose economic wellbeing might⁢ hit a wall. If ​the message⁤ is tighten up your belts and roll up your sleeves, that’s going to be ​kind⁣ of a hard sell.”

REFORMS, THIS⁣ TIME?

The third path, actively ‍switching to a new model, is considered very​ unlikely, based on what happened ‍to Xi’s 60-point programme.

Those plans have barely been ⁣mentioned ⁣since 2015‌ when a capital‍ outflows scare ⁢sent⁢ stocks and the yuan tumbling and engendered⁤ an ⁣official ​aversion to potentially disruptive reforms, analysts‌ say.

China has since backed away from major financial market liberalisation while plans to rein in state behemoths and introduce universal social welfare never quite materialised.

“Right now is ​a time in which there’s‍ a potential for the⁤ train to change direction to a new ⁣model, and I think there’s appetite ⁢to do that,” said Hurst.

“But ⁤at the same time there’s a great fear of the short-term political and social risk, especially of provoking an economic crisis.”

(Additional reporting by Liangping Gao and Kevin Yao; Graphics by Kripa Jayaram; Editing by‍ Marius Zaharia and Sam ‌Holmes)

This ⁣week’s Major Headlines

Mark‍ Mix of⁢ the National ⁤Right to⁤ Work Legal Defense Foundation‍ says his organization is fighting ⁣Big Labor’s Pro Act in Congress.

The Heritage Foundation’s Brent Sadler​ says the recent drone attacks on⁣ Russian soil may be intended to provoke⁤ a ⁣negotiated solution with⁣ Russia

Joe Biden celebrates the US Jobs Report, hides Hunter’s job reports and delivered some nice gas prices just in time for Labor Day Weekend.

(Reuters)‌ – Cryptocurrency exchange Gemini⁣ is ‌trying ‍to rally other creditors behind a plan to wring more money out of bankrupt crypto…‍

By Echo ⁢Wang NEW YORK (Reuters) – Arm Holdings‌ Ltd is targeting a valuation between $50 billion to $55 billion for its… ⁣

(Reuters) -Meta Platforms is considering ⁣paid versions of Facebook‌ and Instagram with no advertisements for users residing in the European ⁤Union (EU)…

(Reuters) – Shares in Dell Technologies Inc rose⁤ 22.2% and⁣ hit a record high on Friday ⁣after it ‌raised full-year ‍financial forecasts…