San Francisco mayor raises transgender flag (Pax Ahimsa Gethen/Wikimedia Commons)
California lawmakers are proposing an engaging solution to address biases in maternity care. They want to implement mandatory training for OB-GYNs, midwives, and even maternity office receptionists, emphasizing that pregnancy and childbirth are not exclusively female experiences.
The recently introduced legislation by Democrats introduces the terms “birthing people” and “nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience” to refer to pregnant individuals. It would require all individuals involved in maternity care, including hospital staff, doctors, nurses, and alternative birth centers, to undergo semi-annual training. The aim is to dismantle the ”multiple layers of potential biases” surrounding the perception that only women can become pregnant.
Hospitals, medical offices, and birth centers would be required to implement state-sanctioned training, although the bill does not specify who would develop the training. Failure to comply could result in fines of up to $25,000. Additionally, birth centers have the option to provide more frequent training if they believe their staff still exhibit biases.
This groundbreaking legislation is a response to the efforts of transgender activists and government officials to promote trans inclusivity by removing female-centered language from women’s healthcare. For instance, the CDC faced criticism last year for endorsing drug-induced “chestfeeding” by transgender men, regardless of potential health risks for infants. Academic journals and media outlets have also been using terms like “pregnant and lactating persons” for years.
Given the Democratic supermajority in California’s legislature, this bill, coauthored by members of the California Legislative Black Caucus, has a high chance of passing. However, critics argue that it is misleading since it expands existing law aimed at reducing black maternal mortality. Cynthia Cravens, a San Francisco Democrat running for state senate, believes the proposal prioritizes gender identity over biological sex and could further strain California’s already vulnerable maternal care system.
Opponents of the bill argue that it undermines women’s sex-based protections. Kara Dansky, president of Women’s Declaration International USA, a group advocating for women’s sex-based rights, describes the measure as “draconian” and suggests that it violates free speech principles by requiring health practitioners to participate in training that denies the biological reality of sex.
The lead author of the bill is Assemblywoman Lori Wilson (D.), who did not respond to a request for comment. Last year, Wilson proposed a bill that would favor parents supporting their child’s gender transition in custody disputes. Despite facing strong opposition, the legislation was ultimately vetoed by the governor.
What is the significance of mandatory training for healthcare professionals involved in maternity care in terms of creating a more inclusive environment for pregnant individuals?
Ment officials to ensure that all individuals, regardless of gender identity, receive inclusive and respectful maternity care. It acknowledges the unique experiences of transgender and nonbinary individuals and aims to challenge traditional norms and biases in the healthcare system.
The bill highlights the need for mandatory training for healthcare professionals involved in maternity care. By requiring OB-GYNs, midwives, and even receptionists to undergo semi-annual training, the legislation aims to create a more inclusive and empathetic environment for pregnant individuals.
The use of terms such as “birthing people” and “nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience” is a deliberate effort to recognize that pregnancy and childbirth are not limited to or exclusive to women. It acknowledges that individuals of various gender identities can and do experience pregnancy and childbirth. By using these terms, the legislation aims to break down the societal perception that only women can become pregnant.
In addition to mandatory training, the bill also emphasizes the role of hospitals, medical offices, and birth centers in implementing state-sanctioned training. While the bill does not specify who would develop the training, it sets clear expectations for compliance. Failure to comply with the training requirements could result in fines of up to $25,000. Birth centers are given the option to provide more frequent training if they believe their staff still exhibit biases.
This proposed legislation is a significant step towards creating a more inclusive and equitable healthcare system. It recognizes the experiences and needs of transgender and nonbinary individuals, challenging the biases and discriminatory practices that have historically been prevalent in maternity care. By training healthcare professionals and holding institutions accountable, the bill aims to ensure that all individuals receive respectful and appropriate care during pregnancy and childbirth.
The introduction of this bill is a testament to the advocacy and activism of transgender individuals and their allies. It represents a collaborative effort between lawmakers, activists, and healthcare providers to address the gaps in maternity care and create a more inclusive and supportive environment for all individuals. It is a reminder of the ongoing struggle for equality and the importance of recognizing and affirming the experiences of all individuals, regardless of their gender identity.
Now loading...