Five flaws in the hush money case against Trump
Former President Donald Trump Faces Criminal Hush Money Case in New York
Former President Donald Trump is set to return to New York for a hearing in his criminal hush money case, which was once considered the weakest of the four indictments he faces but could now be the first to go to trial next month.
Trump was indicted in late March 2023 over an alleged “catch-and-kill” scheme during the 2016 presidential campaign to create false business records to hide an alleged affair with porn star Stormy Daniels. Justice Juan Merchan, who has overseen previous Trump-related cases, will decide whether to proceed with the scheduled trial start, postpone the trial, or dismiss the case as he considers five key arguments from Trump’s defense lawyers.
Legal Observers Questioned the Strength of the Case
Some legal observers initially believed that the indictment could be the weakest of the four Trump faces, as judges rarely sentence first-time offenders to jail time for felony falsification of business records. However, the focus has shifted to proving the case rather than questioning the legal theory behind it.
Since the indictment, two significant developments have occurred: Merchan denied Trump’s request to step aside from the case and rejected his bid to move it to federal court.
Accusations of a “Zombie Case” and Interference
Trump’s attorneys plan to accuse Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg of reviving a ”zombie case” to interfere with Trump’s efforts to regain the presidency in 2024. Bragg’s predecessor declined to pursue an indictment over the same allegations.
The indictment centers on allegations that Trump falsified business records at the Trump Organization to illegally influence the 2016 election by arranging hush money payments. It includes 34 counts related to distorting records and concealing tax crimes.
Arguments Presented by Trump’s Defense Lawyers
Trump’s defense team will present five arguments to support their claim that Bragg’s case should be dismissed:
- Undue delay and statute of limitations: Trump’s lawyers argue that the charges were filed more than six years after the allegations were made public, causing prejudice to Trump.
- Objections to linking hush money payments to federal election: Trump’s attorneys claim that even if the payments were made to help his campaign, they would only be a misdemeanor under New York law.
- Multiplicitous counts should be nixed: Trump’s lawyers argue that charging multiple counts for the same transactions violates the Sixth Amendment.
- Selective prosecution against the GOP front-runner: Trump claims he is being selectively prosecuted and that the indictment is politically motivated.
Trump is expected to appear at the hearing, but it is unlikely he will speak out of turn due to the criminal nature of the case. The hearing will not be televised or recorded, but Trump has previously criticized the indictments as a partisan attack.
In addition to the New York hearing, a hearing in Trump’s state criminal case in Georgia will commence, where his co-defendant’s motion to disqualify the district attorney will be discussed. Trump may also face a ruling in his business fraud trial on Friday.
What potential legal consequences could Trump face if he is convicted in the hush money case, and how could this impact his reputation and political influence
Nce from Politics
Trump’s defense team has accused the prosecution of pursuing a “zombie case” – one that should have been dismissed but was revived for political reasons. They argue that the case is politically motivated and that the prosecution is trying to use it as a tool to tarnish Trump’s reputation. They have pointed to comments made by Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus Vance Jr. and other political figures as evidence of this. However, Merchan has stated that he will not allow politics to interfere with the case and has emphasized the importance of judicial independence. He has made it clear that his decision will be based solely on the facts and the law. The core of the case hinges on the alleged catch-and-kill scheme orchestrated by Trump’s former lawyer, Michael Cohen. The scheme involved paying hush money to Stormy Daniels in exchange for her silence about her alleged affair with Trump. The prosecution argues that Trump played a key role in the scheme and that he should be held accountable for his actions. In response, Trump’s defense team has downplayed his involvement and has argued that the payments were made for legitimate business purposes and not to influence the election. They contend that the alleged affair and the hush money should not be considered criminal offenses, but rather civil matters to be resolved through private arbitration. If the case proceeds to trial and Trump is convicted, he could face serious legal consequences. Falsification of business records is a felony in New York, and convictions can result in significant fines and potentially even prison time. This would be a major blow to Trump’s reputation and could have broader political implications. However, it is important to note that Trump is also facing three other indictments in New York, including charges related to tax fraud and other financial crimes. These cases are seen as potentially more significant and could carry heavier penalties if Trump is found guilty. Regardless of the outcome of the hush money case, Trump’s legal battles are likely to have a lasting impact on his future and the future of the Republican Party. If he is exonerated, it could bolster his political ambitions and solidify his position as a key figure in the conservative movement. On the other hand, if he is convicted, it could tarnish his reputation and make it more difficult for him to regain political influence. The hush money case also highlights the ongoing divide within the Republican Party. While some members remain loyal to Trump and dismiss the charges as politically motivated, others view his legal troubles as a liability and an opportunity for the party to move in a different direction. The upcoming trial will not only determine Trump’s legal fate but also has the potential to shape the future of the judicial system. It will test the ability of the courts to remain impartial in highly politicized cases and will set important precedents for how future cases involving public figures are handled. Legal experts will be closely watching the trial to see how Merchan navigates these complex and contentious issues. His decision on whether to proceed with the trial, postpone it, or dismiss the case will likely be scrutinized and could have far-reaching implications. As the trial date approaches, the anticipation and speculation surrounding Trump’s hush money case continue to grow. The outcome will have reverberations beyond the courtroom, shaping not only Trump’s future but also the future of the Republican Party and the judicial system as a whole. Ultimately, it will be up to Justice Juan Merchan to decide the course of this high-profile case and determine where it falls in the larger legal battle that Donald Trump faces. Whatever the verdict may be, it will undoubtedly leave a lasting impact on the legacy of the former president and the path forward for American politics.The Importance of the Catch-and-Kill Scheme
The Potential Consequences for Trump
The Impact on Trump’s Future and the Republican Party
The Trial and its Potential Impact on the Judicial System
The Wait for a Final Verdict
" Conservative News Daily does not always share or support the views and opinions expressed here; they are just those of the writer."
*As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases
Now loading...