Huge Trans Defeat: High Court Unanimously Rules That Men Are Not Women

Conservative News DailyApril 21, 2025

0 0

The recent ruling by the United Kingdom’s Supreme Court stated that the legal definition of “woman” under the 2010 Equality Act refers specifically to biological women. This decision came after a case brought by For women Scotland, which argued that “trans women” should not be included in the gender quotas for government boards.The court emphasized that while trans individuals have protections under the category of “gender reassignment,” they do not fall under the legal category of “sex” as defined in the Equality Act. The ruling, deemed a victory by advocates for women’s rights, is seen as a step towards ensuring that spaces designated for women remain exclusive to biological women. Critics have raised concerns about the implications of such rulings in relation to broader discussions about gender identity and rights.

“Trans women” are not women.

In case that needed clarifying, the New York Times reported Wednesday that the United Kingdom’s Supreme Court agrees.

According to the Times, the court has decided that “trans women” do not fall within the legal definition of women under the 2010 Equality Act.

In 2018, the Scottish Parliament passed a law to increase the number of women serving on government boards to 50 percent. After the government said “trans women” could be counted in that number, For Women Scotland took them to court arguing they should not be included.

The case traveled through the system until the Supreme Court gave a unanimous ruling Wednesday interpreting the definition of a woman as a “biological woman” under the Equality Act of 2010, a law passed to combat discrimination.

The deputy president of the court, Lord Patrick Hodge, said of the decision, “The unanimous decision of this court is that the terms ‘woman’ and ‘sex’ in the Equality Act 2010 refer to biological women and biological sex.”

Hodge hesitated to go further limiting the scope of the decision to the Equality Act’s language, stating trans people still have protections, but under the protected category of “gender reassignment” not sex.

Co-Director of For Women Scotland Susan Smith commented on the ruling, saying it would make sure “services and spaces designated for women are for women.”

“Everybody should be protected by the Equality Act. This is not about prejudice or bigotry, as some people would say, it’s not about hatred for another community.

“It’s just about saying that there are differences, and biology is one of those differences, and we just need protections based on that,” she added.

Footage was posted to social media platform X on Wednesday, showing For Scotland Women celebrating upon hearing the court’s decision.

Congratulations to @ForWomenScot for this unequivocal win at appeal!

Women’s & lesbians’ rights are human rights. They do not impinge on others’ rights.@UKLabour Gov & public bodies must now review all existing policies to bring them in line with this ruling & common sense. pic.twitter.com/LwUIokuLSC

— LabourWomen’sDeclaration 🦖 (@LabWomenDec) April 16, 2025

How did the West devolve to such a state that a high court needs to affirm that women do not need to worry about men intruding into their spaces?

A degradation of moral traditions rooted in a belief in God is one answer.

Satan, the Great Deceiver, has caused many to worship at the altar of the self, leading the West down a path of immorality.

But stories like this show that there is hope.

What should the U.K. do from here? Have zero tolerance for men pretending to be women.

The U.K. still has a mountain of problems — the suppression of speech being one and not fully rejecting the notion that men can be women being another — but the court’s ruling shows some sense may be returning.