Ridley Scott’s ‘Napoleon’ lacks both truth and myth
“The Man Who Shot Liberty Valence” and the Power of Legends
“This the West, sir. When the legend becomes fact, print the legend,” Maxwell Scott, editor of the Shinbone Star, tells Sen. Ransom Stoddard in John Ford’s 1962 classic. Formerly believing that Stoddard’s past heroic deeds brought order and civilization to his society — and perhaps fearful of running the story or reverent of the mythology he was familiar with — Scott opted not to publish the truth after learning it.
Every civilization relies on its legends and myths to remind people what to believe and why it exists. American history, for instance, has provided the American people with a shared set of stories and figures on which they could rely for national identity and virtues. However, leftists consistently attack this history, undermining our civic traditions.
The Disappointment of Ridley Scott’s “Napoleon”
With great disappointment, I must say that Ridley Scott’s “Napoleon” is terrible. The film’s egregious pacing and critical character inaccuracies detract from the important aspects of Napoleon’s life. But beyond that, the film’s philosophical issues and its attempt to humanize Napoleon only serve to diminish his greatness.
Scott’s film fails to explore the cultural and philosophical milieu in which Napoleon rose to power. Instead, it reduces his life to a two-dimensional psychosexual dramedy, ignoring the moral collapse and chaos of revolutionary France. The film also neglects to show Napoleon’s military conquests and political initiatives accurately, focusing instead on his relationship with his first wife.
By reducing Napoleon to a temperamental man-child, the film fails to capture his unique vision and capability. It overlooks his love and support from France and his significant contributions to the nation. The film’s portrayal of Napoleon is shallow and inaccurate, lacking the depth and complexity that made him a historical figure worth revering.
Scott’s Napoleon is entirely static and two-dimensional, except when confined to his relationship with Josephine. The film misses the opportunity to depict Napoleon as the “synthesis of the inhuman and superhuman,” as Friedrich Nietzsche described him. It fails to capture his calculated, ruthless ambition and his ability to bend the arc of history in his favor.
Napoleon is rightly revered because he is a testament to the rare great man who harnessed his nature to achieve greatness. Motivated by self-interest and a belief in something larger than himself, he changed the world. These are the facts upon which the legend is built. Unfortunately, Scott’s film fails to depict Napoleon accurately and falls short of its source material.
What are the potential consequences of preserving a myth or legend for the greater good, even if it goes against the truth?
Rical narrative, arguing that it is a tool used by the powerful to maintain their dominance and oppress marginalized groups. While it is true that historical narratives can be manipulated and distorted, it is important to recognize the power and value of legends in shaping societies and inspiring individuals.
The movie “The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance” explores the notion of legends and their impact on individuals and society. The main character, Sen. Ransom Stoddard, is a lawyer who believes in the power of law and order to bring about change in the Wild West. However, it is ultimately revealed that it was not the law that tamed the West, but rather the actions of an outlaw named Tom Doniphon. Stoddard is forced to confront the truth that his legend is built on a lie, and he must grapple with the implications of this revelation.
The quote by Maxwell Scott, “When the legend becomes fact, print the legend,” highlights the complex relationship between truth and legend. It suggests that sometimes it is more important to preserve the myth for the greater good, rather than reveal the truth. This raises questions about the role of legends in society and their ability to shape perceptions and inspire action.
Legends and myths have always been a fundamental part of human society. They serve as a collective memory, preserving cultural values, ideals, and historical events. They provide individuals with a sense of belonging and identity, and offer guidance and inspiration through the stories of legendary figures. Legends create a shared narrative that binds a community together, fostering a sense of pride and unity.
In the case of American history, legends such as George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, and Abraham Lincoln have become symbols of the nation’s values and ideals. Their stories inspire generations of Americans to strive for liberty, justice, and equality. While it is important to critically examine historical narratives and acknowledge their flaws, it is also crucial to recognize the power of these legends in shaping national identity and motivating individuals to work towards a better future.
Leftists who criticize the reliance on legends and myths in shaping national identities often argue that these narratives perpetuate inequality and ignore the struggles of marginalized groups. While it is true that some legends may have roots in oppressive systems, it is important to separate the historical context from the value of the myth itself. Legends can evolve and be reinterpreted to reflect a more inclusive and accurate understanding of history.
For example, the legend of the American West has traditionally focused on the exploits of white cowboys and pioneers, often neglecting the contributions and experiences of Native Americans, African Americans, and other marginalized groups. However, contemporary scholars and storytellers are actively working to include these perspectives in the narratives of the Wild West, recognizing the importance of representing a diverse and comprehensive history.
In conclusion, legends and myths play a vital role in shaping societies and inspiring individuals. While it is essential to critically examine and challenge historical narratives, it is equally important to recognize the power of legends in preserving cultural values and inspiring action. The movie “The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance” serves as a reminder of the complexities of truth and legend, and the significance of these stories in our collective consciousness. By embracing a more inclusive and accurate understanding of history, we can create a shared narrative that reflects the diverse experiences and contributions of all individuals.
" Conservative News Daily does not always share or support the views and opinions expressed here; they are just those of the writer."
*As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases
Now loading...