Jewish Trump Supporters Destroy MSG ‘Nazi Rally’ Narrative by Simply Showing Up
The article discusses a recent rally held by Donald Trump at Madison Square Garden, which some Democratic figures labeled as a neo-Nazi event. They drew parallels to a historical rally in 1939 organized by the German-American Bund that also took place in a different Madison Square Garden location, featuring pro-Hitler themes. Prominent Democrats, including James Carville and Hillary Clinton, warned that Trump’s rally echoed this historical context, with Carville expressing that Trump could be a threat to young black men.
Despite these claims, the article highlights the presence of Jewish Trump supporters at the rally, suggesting that many attendees did not view it as a Nazi event. This raised questions about the accuracy of the comparisons made by Democrats, as the rally did not focus on anti-Semitic themes, which are typically central to Nazi rhetoric. The implication is that the Democratic narrative may be exaggerated or unfounded, as evidenced by social media posts showing Jewish attendees expressing their support for Trump. The article argues that without evidence of explicit anti-Jewish sentiments, the term “Nazi rally” may be inappropriate.
Apparently, nobody told Jewish voters they were going to a rally that was literally supporting Hitler in New York City on Sunday.
I know, you would think that they would stay away. Democratic luminary after Democratic luminary warned that GOP standard-bearer Donald Trump’s event at Madison Square Garden was a not-so-secretly neo-Nazi event because, before World War II, a pro-Hitler group held a rally at a different building in a different part of Manhattan also called Madison Square Garden.
The parallels are almost eery! Why, there’s that, and … oh wait, that’s it. They really only have the fact that in February of 1939, the Nazi-boosting German-American Bund held a rally at the old Madison Square Garden, which drew tens of thousands.
“The event, orchestrated to coincide with Washington’s birthday, (February 22nd), featured a thirty-foot image of the first President flanked by red, white and blue bunting and swastikas as the visual backdrop,” NPR affiliate WNYC noted.
The 2024 version included, um, Dr. Phil. Totally alike! Are you not frightened, America?
But nevertheless, the Democrats persisted. First, you had former Clinton adviser James Carville, who would tell it to anyone who would listen …
INSANE: James Carville hyperventilates and absurdly claims that President Trump is mimicking N*zi rallies, warning that Trump will “round up young black men.”
This man is a lunatic. Democrats are completely out of touch with reality.
So much for toning down the rhetoric… pic.twitter.com/R1nGunCFnZ
— Proud Elephant 🇺🇸🦅 (@ProudElephantUS) October 14, 2024
Then you had one of the Clintons themselves, this time Hillary, spouting the same nonsense.
“Now, it may be a leap for some people and a lot of others may think, ‘I don’t want to go there. I don’t want to say that.’ But please open your eyes to the danger that this man poses to our country, because I think it is clear and present for anybody paying attention,” she told CNN.
Crooked Hillary, increasingly bitter about the fact that she will never be president, says that everybody who attends President Trump’s rally at MSG on Sunday is a Nazi. pic.twitter.com/7cUXIlNuor
— Trump War Room (@TrumpWarRoom) October 25, 2024
Heck, you even had one half of the Democratic ticket, Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, also making the comparison between the rallies:
Disgusting: Walz compares Trump’s MSG rally to a 1939 Nazi event. “There’s a direct parallel to a big rally that happened in the mid 1930s at Madison Square Garden.”
Trump is not a Nazi and Kamala is not a Communist. Calling Trump a Nazi is disgusting.
pic.twitter.com/JWAVwBtewe— Eyal Yakoby (@EYakoby) October 27, 2024
“There’s a direct parallel to a big rally that happened in the mid-1930s at Madison Square Garden. And don’t think that he doesn’t know for one second exactly what they’re doing there,” Walz said, absent any evidence.
But, as Jeff Charles noted at Red State, there was ample evidence on social media that Jewish Trump supporters didn’t get the message about a Nazi rally.
How do we know? Well, obviously first, because they were there:
Jews for Trump have arrived at the Madison Square Garden.
Are they still calling it a Nazi rally???? pic.twitter.com/sEnUqaMilk
— Brock Tarner (@brocktarner) October 27, 2024
MAGA SQUARE GARDEN!
Jews are flocking to the MAGA rally in the Garden – the one Crooked Hillary, the Border Czar their Pravda media are calling a “Nazi Rally.” pic.twitter.com/ZQUgglTto9
— JJ Murray (@therealJJMurray) October 27, 2024
This is important since — well, do you know what you kind of need to have in order for an explicit comparison to a Nazi rally hold up? For the speakers and the arena to have a near-monomaniacal focus on alienating, deprecating and threatening Jews.
This includes, first and foremost, scaring them away. It’s almost like the left determined to say this was a Nazi rally without asking whether it fit the one attribute that would tie it to the Nazis.
Strange, that.
Advertise with The Western Journal and reach millions of highly engaged readers, while supporting our work. Advertise Today.
" Conservative News Daily does not always share or support the views and opinions expressed here; they are just those of the writer."
*As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases
