Lawmakers must use state budgets to control unruly public colleges
Americans’ Trust in Higher Education: A Call for Reform
Americans used to trust colleges and universities to hire faculty and admit students on the basis of merit and to teach students without indoctrination. Unfortunately, this deference has waned significantly in recent years. As governors and state lawmakers shape state budgets, here are some ways for democratically elected leaders to express their preferences for higher education.
Expressing Preferences through Budget Language
- Policymakers in most states can tie specific language to higher education appropriations, allowing them to shape the direction of funding.
- Policy ideas can be translated into budget language, such as restricting the use of funds for certain purposes or attaching conditions to funding.
Shifting Funding to Career Colleges
One significant reform is to reduce funding for four-year colleges and allocate more resources to career colleges. This approach makes sense for several reasons:
- Career colleges are often local and affordable, providing students with practical skills.
- Many public colleges have low graduation rates, leaving students with debt and limited job prospects.
Countering Ideologies and Focusing on Workforce Needs
Career colleges may have ideologies of critical theory, but they do not have the excessive spending on diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) seen in public universities. Shifting funding to career colleges could improve student success rates.
Preprofessional degrees, such as journalism and social work, may be better suited for career colleges rather than universities. Moving these fields to two-year programs through apprenticeships can align education with workforce needs.
Lawmakers can address the issue of low-return academic programs by limiting the number of students in non-STEM, non-preprofessional fields. This can be achieved through various measures:
- Restricting state scholarships for certain disciplines
- Imposing spending limits on specific departments
- Prohibiting the use of state funds for disciplines captured by DEI or critical theory
Reforming Curriculum and Ensuring Quality Education
Implementing a high-quality curriculum requires certain measures:
- Requiring economic literacy, civic literacy, and cultural literacy for graduation
- Limiting the core general education curriculum to content-rich courses
- Establishing a new school dedicated to civic education and the liberal arts
By implementing these reforms, states can save taxpayer dollars, improve student outcomes, and strengthen communities. While a completely privatized market for higher education may be ideal, state budget makers have the responsibility to make informed decisions that align with state policies and serve the interests of democracy.
How can reallocating funds to career colleges make education more affordable and accessible for a larger number of students?
Ral reasons. First, career colleges focus on providing job-ready skills and training, which aligns with the needs of the workforce. By directing funds towards these institutions, policymakers can ensure that students are better prepared for the job market.
Second, career colleges often have lower tuition fees compared to four-year colleges and universities. This means that reallocating funds to career colleges can make education more affordable and accessible for a larger number of students.
Lastly, career colleges have a higher rate of post-graduation employment. This means that students who attend career colleges are more likely to secure jobs after completing their education. By investing in institutions that have a proven track record of success in helping students find employment, policymakers can make higher education outcomes more productive and beneficial for both students and the economy.
Encouraging Intellectual Diversity
Another crucial aspect to consider when reforming higher education is the promotion of intellectual diversity. In recent years, there has been a growing concern about the lack of ideological diversity on college campuses. Many institutions have been accused of promoting a one-sided political agenda and suppressing alternative viewpoints.
To address this issue, policymakers can introduce measures to encourage intellectual diversity on college campuses. This can include requiring colleges and universities to have policies in place that protect free speech rights and ensure that all perspectives can be freely expressed. Additionally, funding can be made contingent on institutions demonstrating a commitment to providing a balanced and inclusive educational environment.
By fostering a culture that appreciates and promotes diverse viewpoints, higher education institutions can truly become places of intellectual growth and open discussion, allowing students to develop critical thinking skills and engage in meaningful dialogue.
Accountability Measures
Lastly, to restore trust in higher education, it is essential to implement accountability measures. Policymakers can establish mechanisms that ensure colleges and universities are held accountable for their actions and use of public funds.
One way to achieve this is through performance-based funding. This means that institutions would receive funding based on their ability to achieve predetermined goals, such as graduation rates, job placement rates, and student satisfaction. By linking funding to these outcome metrics, colleges and universities will be incentivized to prioritize student success and be more transparent about their performance.
Additionally, policymakers can require regular audits and evaluations of higher education institutions to ensure that they are adhering to ethical standards and fulfilling their educational mission.
In conclusion, to rebuild Americans’ trust in higher education, policymakers must actively reform the system. By expressing preferences through budget language, shifting funding to career colleges, encouraging intellectual diversity, and implementing accountability measures, higher education can regain its position as a trusted and respected institution that prepares students for success in the workforce and fosters an intellectually diverse society. These reforms are crucial for ensuring that higher education remains relevant and meets the evolving needs of individuals and society as a whole.
" Conservative News Daily does not always share or support the views and opinions expressed here; they are just those of the writer."
Now loading...