The epoch times

Musk’s X takes legal action against California’s moderation law.

Elon Musk’s Social Media Giant X Challenges California Law, Asserting Free Speech Rights

Elon ⁣Musk’s social media giant ⁤X, formerly known as Twitter, is taking legal action against California, challenging‌ the constitutionality of a state law that the company argues infringes its ⁣free speech rights.

The law in question,⁣ California Assembly Bill 587 (AB 587), grants the state the power to dictate terms of service to X and other large social media companies. It requires these platforms to include terms related to content moderation in⁢ their policies. Additionally, the law mandates X⁣ to​ submit semi-annual “terms of service reports” to the California attorney general.

These reports must provide detailed descriptions of⁢ X’s content moderation practices, including how the ⁣company defines and‌ moderates various categories of ⁢content such as hate speech, extremism, disinformation, harassment, and foreign political interference. The reports must also include statistics​ on actions taken to moderate these ‌categories of content.

Related Stories

In​ a lawsuit filed in Sacramento on Friday, X argues that AB 587, signed into law by Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom a year ago, violates the company’s free speech rights ‌under both⁢ the First Amendment to the ⁢United States Constitution and Article I, Section 2 of the​ California Constitution.

X contends that the law infringes on its First Amendment⁤ right to “not speak about controversial topics” and to have the autonomy to decide what it will ⁢and won’t say on such topics.

“[The law] impermissibly‍ interferes with the constitutionally-protected editorial ⁢judgments of⁢ companies such as X Corp., has ⁢both⁣ the purpose and likely effect of pressuring companies such as X Corp. to remove, demonetize, or deprioritize constitutionally-protected speech that the State deems undesirable or harmful, and places⁣ an unjustified and undue burden on social media companies such ⁣as‍ X Corp,” the lawsuit states (pdf).

California has described ​AB 587 as a “transparency measure” aimed at making content moderation ⁣policies and statistics publicly available. ​Supporters ⁣of the law view it as a means⁣ to combat online hate​ and hold social media​ companies accountable for user-generated content.

However, X disputes California’s characterization, citing legislative history and statements from the law’s author, sponsors, ‍and supporters ⁤as evidence that the law’s true ​intent, in the company’s view, is to pressure social media platforms to “eliminate” certain constitutionally-protected ⁢content.

The lawsuit references a quote from a California Assembly Committee on Judiciary⁣ Report⁣ for the 2021–2022‌ session, ‌dated April 27, 2021, which states: “[i]f social media companies are forced to disclose what they do in this regard [i.e., how they moderate online content], it may pressure them to⁤ become better corporate citizens by​ doing more to eliminate hate speech and disinformation.”

X ‍also argues that the law violates the Dormant Commerce Clause by placing an undue burden on interstate commerce, as its⁣ reporting requirements extend‌ beyond California residents and are intended to have “national implications.”

The lawsuit further claims that AB 587 conflicts with the immunity provided⁢ to ‌social media companies under⁢ Section 230 of the U.S. Code, which shields providers and users of interactive⁢ computer services ⁢from liability for actions taken ⁣in good faith to restrict access to objectionable material.

California Assemblymember Jesse ​Gabriel (D-Encino), ‍the​ author of the law, ‌responded to the news of X’s lawsuit on Friday.

“If Twitter has nothing to hide,​ then⁤ they should have no objection to this⁤ bill,” Mr. Gabriel told Politico.


Read More From Original Article Here: Musk’s X Sues California Over Content Moderation Law

" Conservative News Daily does not always share or support the views and opinions expressed here; they are just those of the writer."
*As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases

Related Articles

Sponsored Content
Back to top button
Available for Amazon Prime
Close

Adblock Detected

Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker