oann

NewsGuard: Surrogate the Feds Pay to Keep Watch on the Internet and Be a Judge of the Truth


(Creation of​ OAN’s⁤ Shannon Kelland/Social‌ Media Team)

By Lee Fang
November 17, 2023

(Views expressed by guest commentators may not reflect the views of ‍OAN or its affiliates.)

Advertisement

In May 2021, ⁤L. Gordon Crovitz, a media executive turned start-up⁤ investor, presented Twitter executives with an intriguing proposal​ for a censorship tool.

In the “Twitter Files” revelations about media censorship, Crovitz, ⁤former publisher of the Wall Street Journal, pitched​ his product, NewsGuard,‌ as a “Vaccine Against ​Misinformation.” He emphasized a ⁢”separate product” for internal use by content-moderation teams, ⁢which would utilize artificial intelligence powered‍ by NewsGuard algorithms to quickly screen content based on hashtags and search terms associated with ​dangerous content.

Verbatim: NewsGuard’s Inquisitiveness, and RCI’s⁤ Reply

NewsGuard’s pitch also revealed‌ that it would rely⁢ on official government ⁢sources, such ⁤as the federal Centers for Disease Control, to determine the truth about issues like COVID-19. The company’s allies in content moderation‌ include intelligence and‍ national security⁢ officials, reputation management providers, and government agencies. NewsGuard aimed‍ to ⁢rate the overall⁤ reliability⁤ of ‍websites and combat COVID-19 misinformation from popular websites.

NewsGuard’s failed pitch sheds light on the global trend of governments policing ⁣speech, from disinformation⁢ to‍ dissent. In the⁣ United States, the effort often involves direct appeals to social‍ media platforms and news outlets. More commonly, governments collaborate with seemingly benign non-governmental organizations, ​like the ‍Stanford Internet Observatory, to suppress disapproved speech.

NewsGuard, a for-profit company founded by Crovitz ‌and Steven Brill, seeks to reshape the internet and monetize speech policing. Its ⁣business model involves labeling entire news ​sites as safe or untrustworthy, using a grading system called “nutrition‌ labels.”⁢ Critics argue ‍that ⁢these ratings are ⁣subjective and point out that reputable outlets⁤ like the New York Times receive high ratings despite ​publishing false information.

As NewsGuard ⁤positions itself as the arbiter of trust on the internet, ⁢it claims to have reviewed 95%⁤ of news sources across‍ multiple languages. The company has ‌published reports on disinformation related to China, ⁣the Ukraine-Russia conflict, and the Israel-Hamas wars. NewsGuard has received positive coverage in outlets like CNN​ and the New York Times.

NewsGuard⁤ aims to expand its ​browser ⁤screening‌ process ⁢into various⁢ platforms and institutions. However, its close⁣ ties ⁢to Publicis ​Groupe, a major marketing conglomerate representing pharmaceutical companies ⁣like Pfizer, ⁢raise concerns about conflicts of interest.​ Critics argue that NewsGuard acts ⁤as a proxy for its government‌ and corporate clients‍ to suppress⁣ opposing views.

Several websites, ​including the Daily Sceptic and Consortium News, have challenged their NewsGuard ratings but have faced little interest from the company in engaging in ‍a fair discussion. Instead,⁣ NewsGuard has demanded retractions and downgraded ratings without valid justification.⁣ This raises questions ⁤about NewsGuard’s impartiality and its role in guiding advertisers away from targeted sites.

NewsGuard’s actions ‌have ‍sparked lawsuits and accusations of First Amendment violations and defamation.​ The company’s collaboration with the government and intelligence services further fuels⁤ concerns about its‍ agenda.

Despite the ‌controversies‌ surrounding NewsGuard, ⁢it‍ continues to seek partnerships and​ licenses with ⁣social media platforms and‍ other​ content moderation firms. Its influence in shaping​ online discourse remains significant.

Lee Fang is an independent journalist based⁢ in San Francisco. He writes an investigative newsletter‌ on Substack via www.leefang.com.

Correction, 11:55 PM, Thursday, Nov. 16, 2023This article has been ‌revised to reflect the following correction:
An earlier version misstated an accolade of late ⁣Consortium News founder Robert Parry. He was a Pulitzer Prize finalist, not a⁤ winner.

This article was originally published ⁣by RealClearInvestigations, leefang.com and made available via RealClearWire.

​ Share this post!

Rep. George Santos faces more​ Campaign Misappropriation accusations, Diddy fields accusations of his own​ and a jury⁣ brings⁣ the hammer down on David Depape.

After‌ Presidents Biden and‍ Xi Jinping meet, whistleblowers cite concerns ‍over Sequoia Capital.

Both Iowa and West Virginia are leading an 18-state coalition opposing the ​gag order a federal court has placed on former President Donald ⁣Trump. ​

In​ a 3-2 vote this ​week, the Federal Communications Commission ‌has ‌adopted final rules to prevent so-called⁣ ‘digital⁤ discrimination,’ that many say is rooted in Critical Race Theory. One America’s ⁣Chief White ​House Correspondent Monica Paige breaks down the details.

Spotify expanded its partnership with Google Cloud to use ⁢large language models to help identify a ⁢user’s listening patterns across podcasts and audiobooks.

Starlink has secured a contract to ⁣offer free internet⁢ in Mexico ‍until‌ the end of 2026.

U.S. lawmakers asked Apple Inc to explain the abrupt end of political ‌comedian Jon ⁣Stewart’s television show ⁣on its streaming service.

Elon‍ Musk⁤ denied a ​report that his rocket company SpaceX was discussing an ‌IPO for its satellite internet business, ⁢Starlink.

rnrn

In what ways does NewsGuard aim to combat COVID-19 misinformation from popular websites

Lable on November 17, 2023.

(Views expressed by guest commentators​ may not reflect ⁤the views of ‍OAN or its affiliates.)

Advertisement

In May 2021, ⁤L. Gordon Crovitz, a media executive turned start-up⁤ investor, presented Twitter executives with an intriguing proposal​ for a censorship tool.

In the “Twitter Files” revelations about⁣ media censorship, Crovitz, ⁤former publisher of the Wall Street ​Journal, pitched​ his product, NewsGuard,‌‍ as a “Vaccine‍ Against ​Misinformation.”⁢ He emphasized a ⁢”separate product” for internal⁢ use ⁣by content-moderation teams, ⁢which would utilize‍ artificial intelligence powered‍ by⁢ NewsGuard algorithms⁢ to quickly screen content ⁣based on hashtags ⁢and search terms associated with ​​dangerous​ content.

Verbatim: NewsGuard’s⁣ Inquisitiveness, and RCI’s⁤ Reply

NewsGuard’s pitch also revealed‌ that ⁢it would rely⁢⁣ on official government‍ ⁢sources, such ⁤as the federal Centers for Disease⁣ Control, to⁤ determine the truth about issues like COVID-19. The company’s allies in content moderation‌‍ include ⁣intelligence and‍ national security⁢ officials, reputation management ​providers, and government agencies. ​NewsGuard aimed‍ to‍ ⁢rate the overall⁤ reliability⁤ of ‍websites and combat COVID-19 ‍misinformation from ‍popular websites.

NewsGuard’s failed pitch sheds light on the global trend of⁤ governments policing ⁣speech,​ from disinformation⁢ to‍ dissent. In the⁣ United States, the effort often involves direct appeals to social‍ media platforms and news outlets



" Conservative News Daily does not always share or support the views and opinions expressed here; they are just those of the writer."
*As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases

Related Articles

Sponsored Content
Back to top button
Available for Amazon Prime
Close

Adblock Detected

Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker